Burglar sues homeowner who shot him

David Bailey David McLaughlin

David Bailey, left, and David McLaughlin.

After serving a one-year sentence at an Indiana penitentiary for an attempted burglary that occurred two years ago, a 31-year-old man has filed suit against the homeowner who shot him when he was caught in the act, The Star Press reported.

The property owned by David McLaughlin, of Dunkirk, had been targeted for theft multiple times in the past, prompting him to install a security system that included an alarm.

Around 12:30 a.m. on April 21, 2014, something tripped the alarm, so McLaughlin grabbed his .45-caliber pistol and headed down the stairs and out of his house. Outside, McLaughlin found David A. Bailey running out of his detached garage. McLaughlin opened fire as Bailey ran down an alleyway, McLaughlin running after him. Bailey was struck in the arm, resulting in non-life threatening injuries.

However, McLaughlin was charged with criminal recklessness resulting in serious bodily injury, a Class D felony, and subsequently convicted in September 2014. McLaughlin was sentenced to serve 60 days in jail, four months of home detention and a year of probation.

Judge Max Ludy Jr. called McLaughlin’s actions “reprehensible,” noting that he fired aimlessly down the alleyway.

Likewise, Bailey pleaded guilty to burglary charges and served a one-year sentence. But Bailey says the shooting has forever changed his life with damages that are both “serious and permanent.”

“I can’t lift nothing. I can’t make a fist. I can’t do nothing with it. I got a crow’s feet for hands; my fingers are like curling up,” Bailey, a machinist by trade, told The Daily Beast.

Bailey said his medical bills and other “damages” will easily top $100,000, and he wants McLaughlin to pay, as indicated by the lawsuit filed last week. Bailey, who will remain on electronic home detention until 2018, also noted that he thinks McLaughlin “didn’t get shit” for shooting somebody.

Like the judge, Bailey also thinks McLaughlin acted in a dangerous manner when he began shooting.

“He came running out his yard chasing down the alley and shooting into the dark,” Bailey said. “He shot a lot. I didn’t think he was going to shoot at us. I thought he was going to shoot up in the air until I heard [bullets] flying past my head.”

Bailey said he is lucky to be alive and noted the bullet that hit him was only about two inches from a main artery.

And despite his guilty plea — which he said was coerced in exchange for dropping an additional gun charge — Bailey maintains his innocence and said he did not intend to steal anything from McLaughlin and never entered the man’s garage. In fact, Bailey said it was a friend, who he refuses to name, that broke into the garage, not him.

Bailey said he and his friend were walking to the friend’s house, getting ready to go on a fishing trip the following day, when they passed by McLaughlin’s property and his friend stopped at the garage as Bailey kept walking down the alleyway. Bailey said after McLaughlin came out of his house, the two split up as they ran away and that’s when McLaughlin started firing at Bailey.

“He could have shot into a house and hit a kid—he could have shot anybody. He just shot down a dark black alley with houses all around,” Bailey said. “He didn’t know what he was shooting at or who he was shooting at—he was just was shooting down a dark alley hoping he’d hit something.”

McLaughlin hit Bailey and now he is asking for “a monetary award in an amount sufficient to compensate for all damages.”

McLaughlin’s attorney, Brian Pierce, told reporters that the lawsuit is over the top. “My client thinks it’s outrageous and I tend to agree,” Pierce said. “You don’t ordinarily expect someone to burglarize you and turn around and sue you for damages.”

Latest Reviews

  • Springfield SAINT: Your High-Value AR-15

    The Springfield Armory SAINT offers a high-value, no-frills-required AR-15 platform. We put it through its paces to see if it's worth adding to your collection. After several trips to the range, we can confirm this is a great gun.

    Read More
  • The Sig Sauer P320 X5 Legion is an Amazing Pistol

    The Sig Sauer p320 X5 Legion has been on the market for a little while now. So I wanted to bring you a review after shooting more than 30,000 rounds through mine over a year of competing in 3-gun and USPSA.

    Read More
  • 17 Reasons to Love the Glock 17

    Glock 17s are trusted by law enforcement and militaries around the world. But they are also great guns for civilians. Here are our top 17 reasons to get a Glock 17.

    Read More
  • Sig P320 vs. Sig P365 for Concealed Carry

    Sig’s P365 and P320 offer two great options for concealed carry. Their compact sizes and high magazine capacities make them excellent choices for everyday carry. They're also easy to customize.

    Read More