Deaths of Alton Sterling, Philando Castile, fuel police tensions

07/8/16 11:39 AM | by

Two recent shootings of Alton Sterling in Baton Rouge and Philando Castile near St. Paul, Minnesota remind us of the oppositional relationship between the police and ordinary citizens in America.

The Sterling case isn’t clear at this point, but the killing of Castile, a school cafeteria supervisor with a concealed carry license, appears to be a grossly excessive response by the officer during what should have been a routine traffic stop, and if race was a motivating factor, that makes the act so much the worse.  All carry license holders need to watch this case.

Both of these incidents fit into the broader narrative of abuse experienced by minorities in their encounters with law enforcement.  This conflict is one that has gone on for a long time.

When police shootings show up in the news, reporters often use a distinction in language between the cops and civilians, as if there’s some actual separation.  But this is in fact a misuse of words that reveals a bigger misconception about the role of law enforcement in a free society.

The word, police, comes ultimately from the ancient Greek polis, city.  The police originally were city administrators and only took on its current meaning in the nineteenth century.   Civilian has the same root idea, in this case the Latin civilis, a word dealing with public life or the acts of a citizen.  Civilian specifically has been used as a contrast with military for a long time, and both civilian and police are participants in the life of the city.

In Britain, this distinction between the police and the army is the reason that law enforcement in that country typically go unarmed during the course of carrying out their duties.  The founder of the Metropolitan Police, Robert Peel, wanted a clear line separating soldiers in their red uniforms from police officers in blue, preventing the impression that the country was under martial law.  This today is meant to express the role of officers as serving the people, rather than the state.  In that way, the British attitude toward the police and military is similar to what motivated our founders to add the Second Amendment to our Constitution.  It’s a reminder that government power comes from the people and must serve their interests.

And yet, in modern America, we’re witnessing and in too many ways allowing the militarization of law enforcement.  Using language that creates an artificial divide between police and the rest of us only serves to make this worse.  We’ve gone from the image of Will Kane or Andy Taylor—who did at times carry a gun—to Judge Dredd, and this is not the direction a free society can long endure.

In part, this is the result of our decades-long War on Drugs, a war that has brought nothing but misery and the erosion of constitutional protections to our streets, along with cops who look more like urban commandos.  The War on Terror has only pushed us deeper into what is becoming more like a police state than a nation of free citizens served by our government.

If we care about rights—about gun rights, as the Castile case may illustrate, but about all rights, in fact—we have to pull ourselves back from the brink.  Owning and carrying firearms is only one part of that.  Our elected officials also have to be reminded regularly why we allow them to hold office and voted out if they cannot conform to their duties, including the oversight of executive agencies such as the police.

The views and opinions expressed in this post are those of the author’s and do not necessarily reflect the position of Guns.com.

Latest Reviews

  • Winchester Snow Goose

    Winchester Hits Hard with Xpert Snow Goose Ammo

    Modern ammunition manufacturers are recognizing the demand for specialty rounds among dedicated hunters -- enter Winchester’s Snow Goose.

    Read Now
  • Beretta A400

    Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus Ready for the Worst of Waterfowling

    While the jury remains out on measuring recoil in the duck blind, the one certainty is that the new iteration...

    Read Now
  • Asfaleia

    Asfaleia Creates Designer Concealed Carry, Bulletproof Tote

    A new concealed carry bag company is on the rise, introducing a more stylish approach to the concealed carry conundrum.

    Read Now
  • The Sig P365 SAS - First 100 Rounds and Initial Thoughts

    At first look, the Sig Anti Snag (SAS) model has many exciting features, including new sights in the familiar small...

    Read Now