Pitting two magnum revolvers against each other: .357 vs 44 (VIDEO)

06/1/18 10:00 AM | by

Pitting two magnum revolvers against each other: .357 vs. 44 (VIDEO)

Just how big a difference is it between the two calibers when compared to similar loads from similar wheel guns?

Paul Harrell does the yeoman job of trying to stack the two classic revolver magnum calibers against each other by using commercially available loadings with 180-grain projectiles. To balance the guns, he uses a Smith & Wesson Model 29 in .44 and a companion S&W Model 686-6 in .357 — both big Smiths with 6-inch barrels.

Then comes Chrono data, followed up with a few spicier loadings more catered to the calibers’ performance envelope. And for the masses, there is a round of destructive testing against some $2 concrete cinder blocks and with gross combination targets made of fruit, meat, and fabric. The latter gets kinda nasty:

Like two-fingers in a rack of perforated ribs nasty

In short, take your time with this one if you are a fan of either caliber– or just hate ribs.

Latest Reviews

  • P320

    Gun Review: The Sig Sauer P320 Compact (VIDEO)

    For the last five years, the Sig Sauer P320 compact has been one of the top choices for CCW. So...

    Read Now
  • 5 Concealed Carry Holsters for Exercising (VIDEO)

    Guns.com has done the heavy lifting, creating a sampling of five concealed carry holsters designed for healthier fit lifestyle.

    Read Now
  • Summer Carry: 22 Years Toting the Same .38 Snub

    Summer Carry: 22 Years Toting the Same S&W .38 Snub

    For those situations where a more full-sized gun isn't on the schedule, this Smith & Wesson Model 642 Airweight has...

    Read Now
  • Single Stack

    Kahr PM9: An Excellent Single Stack for Concealed Carry

    One of Kahr Arms most popular models, the PM9 is among the smallest and lightest single-stack 9mm handguns in today’s...

    Read Now