SASS Revolvers Square Off: Colt SA Army vs Ruger Vaquero

11/19/19 5:00 AM | by

A beautiful case hardened Colt SA Army (Photo: Don Summers/

The Colt SA Army and Ruger Vaquero are two popular options for those looking to wet their feet in the world of Single Action Shooting Sports. With a variety of wheelguns at their disposal, what is it about these two that is so appealing for SASS shooters?

A Little History

A beautiful case hardened Colt SA Army (Photo: Don Summers/


Introduced in 1873, the Colt SA Army was immediately adopted by the U.S. Army. Colt manufactured the guns until 1941 when production ground to halt for the company to better support the mounting war effort. At the close of WWII, the SA Army’s design was deemed obsolete with Colt closing the book on the SA Army. The revolver’s story, however, wasn’t over just yet. The 1950s gave rise to many western-themed cowboy shows, resulting in the resurrection of the SA Army due to high demand. Colt introduced its second generation of SA Army in 1956 and continued churning out the revolver until 1974 when Colt, again, pulled the plug.

The classic grips of a Colt SA Army (Photo: Don Summers/

The wheelgun laid dormant for two years until, in 1976, the SA Army remerged bearing a new cylinder bushing and thread pitch. This third-generation is still in production today and up until the 1990s was one of the few guns available for cowboy shooters.

A cowboy gun still finds a home on the range (Photo: Don Summers/

Though Colt was one of the few providing cowboy guns for competition, it wasn’t long until Ruger took notice of the growing popularity of cowboy shooting. Subsequently, the gun maker launched the Ruger Vaquero to cater to that market.

Similar to Ruger’s Blackhawk, the Vaquero sports fixed sights and a variety of grips. The Vaquero comes chambered in popular cowboy calibers including .45 Colt, .44 Magnum, .357 Magnum, and .44-40 Win. The gun also offers a wide selection of barrel lengths from 3.75-inches to 7.5-inches. For a more complete history of the Colt SA Army click here for our feature.


Battle of the SASS Guns: Colt SA Army vs. Ruger Vaquero

For many cowboy shooters gun selection largely centers around budget. Despite both the Colt SA Army and Ruger Vaquero offering proven designs, earning accolades among competition shooters, one tends to come priced significantly higher than the other.

First and second-generation Colt SA Armies often win with collectors but at several thousand dollars a pop, you’ll likely want to store these models on a shelf. If the Colt SA Army speaks to you, opt for the more recent third generation as it’s starting price is around $1,980.

The Ruger Vaquero is popular among SASS Shooters (Photo: Don Summers/

If budget is the driving factor, the Ruger Vaquero is considerably more affordable. Prices on the Vaquero start around $660, making it a great option for those looking to cut costs.


Remember, before slinging lead in competition, whichever model you choose needs to undergo a trip to a quality, certified gunsmith. SASS expert and Cowboy Chronicle Editor John Clarke told that successful competitors know the value of maintenance.

“You want to get these guns ‘slicked up’ and get the internals smoothed out and the trigger worked on for competition shooting,” Clarke commented.

The Vaquero is an affordable option for the new shooter to SASS (Photo: Don Summers/

Final Thoughts

Models aside, Clarke says shooters can’t go wrong with either model. “Both guns are excellent and will give you years of service,” said Clarke.

Whether you’re drooling over an early generation Colt SA Army for collecting or you plan on taking a Ruger Vaquero out to SASS competitions, remember that has you covered. With many certified used options in our inventory, you’re bound to find something that fits within your budget.

John Clark is the editor of the Cowboy Chronicle shown here with his Colt SA Army and Ruger Vaquero (Photo: Don Summers/

Latest Reviews

  • Winchester Snow Goose

    Winchester Hits Hard with Xpert Snow Goose Ammo

    Modern ammunition manufacturers are recognizing the demand for specialty rounds among dedicated hunters -- enter Winchester’s Snow Goose.

    Read Now
  • Beretta A400

    Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus Ready for the Worst of Waterfowling

    While the jury remains out on measuring recoil in the duck blind, the one certainty is that the new iteration...

    Read Now
  • Asfaleia

    Asfaleia Creates Designer Concealed Carry, Bulletproof Tote

    A new concealed carry bag company is on the rise, introducing a more stylish approach to the concealed carry conundrum.

    Read Now
  • The Sig P365 SAS - First 100 Rounds and Initial Thoughts

    At first look, the Sig Anti Snag (SAS) model has many exciting features, including new sights in the familiar small...

    Read Now