Gun Review: Glock 43 vs Sig Sauer P365 in EDC battle (VIDEO)

Among choices for concealed carry pistols, the Glock 43 has been one of the most popular since its 2015 release. It was adopted more or less happily by Glock fans who nevertheless bemoaned its anemic six-plus-one capacity. It even earned a satirical Hitler video  for its shortcomings.

The Glock 43 was adopted by throngs of folks who felt it was the best among lots of unsatisfactory choices. Certainly, aftermarket options made it better. Night sights, light attachments, and magazine extensions helped. Lots of us, myself included, carry a G43.

Birds of a feather! Both reliable and concealment-friendly. (Photo: Eve Flanigan/Guns.com)

Three years later, SHOT Show 2018 saw the unveiling of the Sig Sauer P365. Online chatter was instantaneous. This new pistol was a strange beast, with a profile strikingly similar to that of the G43, but with a major difference: it was to be sold with two ten-round magazines, one with a flat floorplate and one with a pinky rest, just like the G43. But it seemed there was sorcery involved—how could a magazine not much bigger than the G43’s hold ten whole rounds?

These two firearms have a few things in common, other than size and weight. Trigger weight and travel are similar, with the break on the P365 being less clunky than that of the Glock. Both have roomy trigger guards. Both easily drop magazines without a tug, assuming the release is performed without the meat of the hand running interference with gravity at the bottom of the mag well.

Choosing between these models isn’t a discussion I’d even muster if both models weren’t dependable. They are. I’ve run multiple brands and grain weights through both guns. They just run. To me this is the one critical factor in choosing a concealment gun—it must go bang when it’s time.

Viewed from the rear, the 43 appears slightly taller here, but the Sig’s official height is a tiny 0.05 inches greater. (Photo: Eve Flanigan/Guns.com)

The P365 sports forward cocking serrations, a rail, and night sights; the G43 doesn’t. The G43 has a reversible magazine release; the Sig doesn’t, though it’s worth noting that functional issues have been reported by many owners who’ve switched their G43’s to lefty configuration. Obsessed with finger/thumb grooves? The G43 has them.

Having carried and used the P365 for a little more than a month now, in the same holster that used to carry a G43, observations by myself and other shooters have come up with theories about the little gun’s remarkable capacity. One colleague who fired the Sig and is a self-described grip squeezer said the grip’s walls are so thin he feels them flex while using it. I’ve noticed the seeming miniaturization of parts that interface with the magazine. The series of ledges that secure the mag inside the well and comprise the follower/slide lock/side interface are very slim. That means more room for a mag. It’s a long-overdue overhaul of concealment pistol design. However, the G43 remains a contender thanks to a trait of the P365 that’s sure to turn some folks off.

The comparative price of these guns can be considered the difference between the upgrade to tritium night sights on the Glock versus inclusion of that asset from the get-go on the Sig.

With each wearing an extended magazine floorplate, the little guns are nearly identical in size. (Photo: Eve Flanigan/Guns.com)

Here’s the sticking point: the P365, on most occasions when a human digit is in the vicinity of the slide lock lever during the firing sequence, does not go to lockback when the mag is empty. For a concealment gun that holds 11 rounds, that’s shipped with an extra mag that holds another 10, I can put up with what amounts to an AK-style reload when the firing sequence is sufficiently intense to make a body forget to count.

P365 for the win, for me at least. There are worse backup guns than the G43, and only one I’ve found that I like better: the P365.

SPEC COMPARISON

                                                    Glock 43              Sig Sauer P365

Barrel length                    3.4 inches                         3.1 inches

Trigger pull weight        5.5 pounds                       5.2 pounds

Overall length                  6.26 inches                       5.8 inches

Overall height                  4.25 inches                       4.30 inches

Width                                   1.0 inches                         1.0 inches

Weight, loaded                22.36 ounces                   25.15 ounce

Capacity                                6 +1                                    10 +1

  

The Glock 43 in this feature is not entirely stock. It has a custom Cerakote job and a Pearce magazine extension, increasing mag capacity to seven.

Latest Reviews

  • Tuck & Carry: CCW in a Skirt

    Aimed at those who want the comfort and convenience of a skirt but with the protection of a holstered gun, the Tuck & Carry occupies what I term apparel holsters -- that is clothing/holster duos.

    Read More
  • The Marlin Dark in .45-70 is Stealthy and Modern

    Flash forward the lever gun of Western lore to the 2020s, where Marlin has taken that classic design and given it a modern upgrade. Meet the Marlin Dark.

    Read More
  • Gear Review: Sig Sauer Tango 6T 1-6

    Sig Sauer has long been a big name in the firearms industry, so it came as no surprise several years ago when Sig filled out its repertoire with its own optics line. Today, we’re looking at the Tango 6T, a 1-6 low power variable optic.

    Read More
  • First Look: Hornady 6mm ARC

    Hornady brought another impressive project to the shooting public in 2020 with the introduction of the 6mm Advanced Rifle Cartridge.

    Read More

Loading