Shield Arms SA-9 Review: Overbuilt PCC That Makes Its Mark
Montana-based Shield Arms does things in a unique way, and the gun that landed in my hands last October is no exception. The SA-9 FLR piqued my interest when we toured the factory last year. While the company cut its teeth selling basepads for Glock magazines, this PCC is proving to me that Shield has a lot more in store when it comes to making guns.
Shield Arms paired up with Midwest Industries to deliver on the handguard. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
When I pulled the SA-9 out of the box, the first things that struck me were the attention to detail and craftsmanship put into this firearm. This is also reflected in the company Shield chooses to keep when building out the platform.
The safety selector and charging handle from Radian give it a classy feel. I love that they set up the safety selector to have a 45-degree throw. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
The gun comes with a Midwest Industries 6-inch Combat Series handguard. Everything I’ve encountered from Midwest Industries has been extremely high quality, so it’s great to see Shield Arms teaming up with such a reputable manufacturer.
The same could be said of the safety selector, charging handle, and trigger. After seeing Shield Arms’ manufacturing facilities, I know the company could have made these in house. Instead, Shield chose to surround the gun with winners already known in the industry. The Radian Raptor charging handle feels overbuilt for the platform but runs so smoothly.
This trigger from Hiperfire is one of the best I've ever had the pleasure of shooting. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
You could echo that sentiment about the Radian Talon Ambi safety selector, which is set up for a 45-degree throw. It works naturally in this setting and is a cinch to manipulate. When it comes to the trigger, I dry-fired it once, and that was enough to know that the Hiperfire Enhanced Duty Designated Marksman Trigger was one of the best I’ve ever felt. Oddly enough, this isn't the same trigger that ships with the SA-9 today, but it does show the versatility of the platform to accept third-party triggers. Either way, it had me itching to get on the range.
As an added bonus, the gun ships with two of Shield's magazines and a nice sling. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
Finally, each gun ships with two Glock mags with Shield Arms +5 basepads – some of the best in the business – and a Mountain Partisan sling from Shield’s sister company.
Proprietary Systems and Unique Differences
The patents framed in the Shield Arms offices. Note the folding adapter at left. (Photo: Chris Eger/Guns.com)
My other big note is the FLR, or folding lower receiver, part of this gun. This proprietary system treats the folder more like a traditional AR, with the buffer integrated into the SB Tactical pistol brace. I’ve been shooting a lot of roller-delayed PCCs lately, so I was eager to see and try something totally different. The Shield Arms design has pros and cons, but we’ll dissect that in the range section.
The patent in action. The end user has the ability to change the buffer weights to make this one of the more customizable PCCs I've come across in that regard. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
The locking mechanism was easily activated and needed no break-in period. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
Besides the trigger, the only other difference between my model and Shield's current model is the muzzle device. The gun they shipped me has a Dead Air KeyMo muzzle device, while the guns they sell now ship with a more standard A2 birdcage. I think each has benefits and drawbacks, but again, we’ll get to those in a minute.
For transparancy, Shield Arms sent this gun for review and all testing and evaluation has been done on this one gun.
The only thing you won't find on the new models that came on my gun is the KeyMo muzzle adapter. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
Specs
Caliber: 9mm Capacity: 20+1 – Ships with two 20-round mags, but takes any Glock 19 mag Length: 13 inches (folded), 23.5 inches (unfolded) Barrel Length: 7.5 inches Barrel Material: 4150 Chrome Moly Vanadium steel with a QPQ Corrosion Resistant Finish Weight: 5 pounds, 9 ounces
Initial Shots
The first 10-shot group from the SA-9 at 40 feet. There is a trend here I'll discuss in a few captions. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
The first shots confirmed that this gun isn’t just a pleasure to shoot, it's also among the most accurate PCCs I’ve shot. Much of that can be ascribed to the Hiperfire Enhanced Duty Designated Marksman Trigger. What a marksman trigger is doing in a PCC is beyond me, but you won’t find me complaining about it. This is one of the nicest triggers I’ve ever felt. There is zero take-up and a crisp, easy break with a short reset to get you back on target quickly.
Eating the heart out of a target at 40 feet was easy work any day with the SA-9. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
The only downside to the initial firing came when I realized that, because of how the buffer system on the gun works, I can’t fire while the brace is folded. Sure, firing while folded is cool. But unless you’re working a security job where you’ll be in and out of a vehicle a lot, I don’t see a need to shoot folded. It’s fun on the range, but there is little practical use to it.
I've had the TSR-1 for a long time now and have run it on a lot of different guns. It seemed more fitting for the SA-9 than any of the other guns I've shot with it. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
I paired the SA-9 with a U.S. Optics TSR-1, which seemed appropriate as the company’s HQ is in Kalispell, Montana. The optic added to the trigger for an incredibly accurate gun. I wish the TSR-1 were shake-awake, but it's a bit of an older design. As I ran up the round count, it never lost zero and functioned reliably to complement the SA-9 perfectly.
Running Up the Round Count
Since I got the SA-9 in October, I’ve put around 1,500 rounds through it without a single hiccup – until the last magazine I shot. I had a single malfunction, a failure to chamber a round, with Gold Dot Carbine ammo on the last round of the mag. Life goes that way sometimes, but I would say one malfunction for 1,500 rounds is pretty good. This includes lots of Federal ammo, ranging from Syntech to Hydra-shok and everything in between.
The SA-9 runs like a fine-tuned race car on the range, and I'm all here for it. (Photo: Paul Peterson/Guns.com)
I also shot lots of PMC Bronze and Turkish surplus ammo through it. One brand in particular was causing quite a few primer strike issues with some handguns I had, but the SA-9 chewed through it all, including cycling it through multiple 50-round Magpul drummy mags. So, I’ll chalk that last malfunction up to dumb luck, as it never skipped a beat prior.
I love a drummy mag – Turkish ammo not so much, but it works for training. Shot at 25 feet at a frequency of around one shot per second. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
While you can adjust the buffer weights in this design, I never felt the need. It ran like such a champ out of the box that I wanted to keep it as is. It should be noted that Shield Arms sent this gun, and all testing has been done on this one gun without any breakdown for cleaning or maintenance.
I look forward to taking the SA-9 to the range every time, and I look forward to the day I get to run through some training classes with it. I appreciate that Shield Arms made this system run on Glock mags, since that opens a lot of aftermarket options for different mags.
The Mountain Partisan sling has come in handy and is comfortable to wear around the range. I appreciate the bungee functionality and look forward to training more with these slings.
Shooting a but low is all me, as I never adjusted the optic after a quick initial zero – d'oh! So, take these target shots with a grain of salt. This one from 25 feet again, with the same frequency as above. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
My only other addition was a Magpul handstop. I like these on PCCs as a final safety precaution, and I feel like they add a bit more control as well. The SA-9 no longer ships with the KeyMo muzzle device, instead featuring a more standard A2-style birdcage. Some would say this is a detriment, because 9mm doesn’t need a birdcage the same way a rifle might. On the other hand, with the KeyMo muzzle device, you’re locked into Dead Air products. Either muzzle device can be removed to reveal a standard 1/2x28 thread pitch.
A mag dump from both the Angstadt Arms MDP9 (top) and Shield Arms SA-9 (bottom). Granted, it's not quite apples to apples, as the MDP sports only a single-point sling vs. the SB Tactical brace on the SA-9, but that is a different article for a different day... (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
Pros and Cons
Pros:
Overbuilt PCC runs like a tank
Accepts third-party triggers, Hiperfire trigger is incredible
Radian safety selector and charging handle add to the high-end feel
Accurate and reliable
Wants to run fast and has no issues doing so
SB Tactical SBA3 brace adds good amount of adjustability
Included Mountain Partisan sling is a boon
Great price point for everything you get
Customizable buffer system
Cons:
Doesn’t fire while folded
No longer comes with KeyMo muzzle device, if you’re already a Dead Air guy
Conclusion
After to traveling to Montana last year, I can tell you it may be among the most sparsely populated states in the Union, but it produces some true gems. (Photo: Seth Rodgers/Guns.com)
This feels like the start of a beautiful relationship with the SA-9. I’m looking forward to running some classes with it and adding a suppressor. I should probably break it down for a cleaning, but it doesn’t feel like it really needs it. I bet I could easily double my round count before that needs to happen, but I don’t clean my guns religiously.
If you’re looking for your next home defense PCC, truck gun, competition gun or any combo of the above, the SA-9 would perform well in any of those roles.