Case at Supreme Court challenges legitimacy of the National Firearms Act

01/17/19 5:00 AM | by

Case at Supreme Court challenges legitimacy of the National Firearms Act

Kettler was found guilty on one count of purchasing the unregistered suppressor and faced a as much as 10 years in prison over his resulting failure to pay a $200 tax to federal regulators. (Photo: Chris Eger/Guns.com)

Kettler was found guilty on one count of purchasing the unregistered suppressor and faced an as much as 10 years in prison over his resulting failure to pay a $200 tax to federal regulators. (Photo: Chris Eger/Guns.com)

The appeal to the country’s high court of a Kansas man found guilty of an NFA violation aims to “cut to the heart of the National Firearms Act.”

Jeremy Kettler in 2017 was found guilty of violating federal laws concerning the manufacturing and selling of suppressors and was given a year’s probation on a single count of possession of an unregistered NFA item. With the conviction upheld on appeal to the 10th U.S. Circuit last October, Kettler is now pursuing his case with the help of a gun rights group, to the Supreme Court.

“Jeremy Kettler’s petition presents solid, well-argued questions important to all gun owners, and we hope the Court will grant certiorari to decide them,” said Erich Pratt, executive director of Gun Owners of America and its Gun Owners Foundation legal arm, who is supporting the continued appeal.

The 46-page petition to the high court argues that the NFA, which was adopted in 1934, is unconstitutional and that it is, in essence, a money-losing tax that produces no revenue for the government while effectively criminalizing the devices it controls. Pointing that the taxes charged on the making and transfer of items such as suppressors are only collected by federal firearm regulators and not by the IRS, and that similar failures to pay a $200 tax due to the IRS would not produce a felony punishable by up to 10 years in prison, Kettler’s attorneys argue that the NFA is, in fact, a regulatory scheme.

“In other words, the purpose of this requirement is purely gun control, not tax collection,” says the filing before going on to contend, “The $200 ‘tax’ is just the hook by which the government continues to claim that the NFA is a tax, instead of what it so obviously has become — unconstitutional gun control.”

Making the argument that the Heller case, decided by the high court a decade ago, can be interpreted to protect suppressors– now numbering over 1.3 million– under the Second Amendment, the petition argues that, “Certainly, suppressors are far more common today than handguns were in Washington, D.C. in 2008 when this Court determined that the categorical ban on handguns in the home was unconstitutional.”

Kettler, a disabled combat veteran, came under investigation in 2014 when he posted a video on social media of a suppressor he bought at a local Army-Navy surplus store without a tax stamp or ATF paperwork. According to court documents, the man who sold him the silencer, Shane Cox, did not have a federal license to manufacture suppressors and violated the NFA as he didn’t pay the special tax or register the items in accordance with the act. At trial, the men used a defense that Kansas state law insulated them from prosecution by the federal government, while the court did not concur.

In the end, Cox was found guilty on eight counts of illegally making and marketing firearms and not guilty in two other counts involving possession of a destructive device. Kettler was found guilty on one count of purchasing the unregistered suppressor. Both received probation.

While centered on suppressors, Pratt said this week that Kettler’s pending appeal to the Supreme Court challenges the NFA as a whole.

“GOA/GOF have stood for the right to own ‘bearable arms’ of all types, and firearms accessories as well — including suppressors and machine guns,” Pratt said. “The arguments presented by GOA/GOF cut to the heart of the National Firearms Act.”

Latest Reviews

  • Serbu Shorty

    Fruit and cabbage no match for the Serbu Super Shorty (VIDEO)

    Manufactured by Serbu Firearms in Tampa, the Shorty claims to be the shortest pump action shotgun on the market today.

    Read Now
  • Magnum BFG

    Hunt big or go home: Magnum Research BFR in .30-30 (VIDEO)

    From the company of Desert Eagle fame comes this full line of over-built, serious single action revolvers. Guns.com gets friendly...

    Read Now
  • Revision, Caller, Seeker, Pursuer

    Revision Outdoor brings style, safety to outdoor adventures

    Kicking off its new consumer driven lineup, Revision Outdoor brings three sunglasses to civilians wanting a cooler vibe in the...

    Read Now
  • Sig Sauer M400 Tread: The New Face of Freedom (VIDEO)

    Sig Sauer's TREAD is not just another cheap “entry level” direct impingement rifle produced en masse for a saturated market.

    Read Now